MOCpages : Share your LEGO® creations
LEGO models my own creation MOCpages toys shop MELO R6: John Snyder vs. Classical BricksCastle
Welcome to the world's greatest LEGO fan community!
Explore cool creations, share your own, and have lots of fun together.  ~  It's all free!
MELO R6: John Snyder vs. Classical Bricks
About this creation
Category: Switched Teams
My opponent's homepage
The MELO Homepage


My build for the 6th and final round of the 2017 Middle Earth LEGO Olympics. The category was ĎSwitched Teamsí; so someone who was a villein would now be a good guy, and a place like Rivendell would be evil, etc. I decided to do Minas Morgul, which is the fortress of the Witch King in the Lord of the Rings, so in my version the Witch King is now a noble leader with a valiant force of warriors guarding the splendid fortress. In order to make it look less scary/bad guy-ish, I opted for a white/grey colorscheme and changed the architecture to be slightly less pointy (though I did keep the buttresses and battlements rather spiky), while still keeping the same general layout. Iím quite pleased with the result, and although I didnít plan on it getting quite this big, itís now my heaviest build to date, weighing a smashing 31.2 pounds!

There are also a few things you can try to find in this build, if you would like (though not many of them are very well hidden, I admit!):
4 frogs
1 bear
2 hedgehogs
1 bird in a birds nest
3 chickens
2 goats































More pictures on Brickbuilt
Thanks for looking, C&C welcome!



Comments

 I like it 
  August 7, 2017
Were I still a judge, you'd have my bow. A close and beautiful match, but (to balance the scales a bit) I'd go so far as to say yours better represents the category. I immediately recognized it as Minis Morgul. Your presentation and composition look a bit more complete as well and take it up a notch in my humble opinion. Good luck with the remaining judge.
 I like it 
  August 6, 2017
I apologize for the late vote (I had no access to MOCpages this week) and I vote for John Snyder! I try to give you a more detailed vote soon!
  August 6, 2017
I don't feel like it doesn't fit the category, just not as well as Classical's. That being said I spent close on a week going back and forth on which one to vote for, so it was a very close call. You have a build to be very proud of, good luck with the last judge/s.
 I made it 
  August 5, 2017
Thanks a lot everyone, very glad you like how it turned out! As far as not fitting the category, I have to respectfully disagree. Minas Morgul is one of the most evil places in Middle Earth at the time of LOTR. So if it switched sides, wouldn't you expect to be incredibly pure and clean? Even in this round's category description, it suggests 'a white Barad-dur with a beautiful woman's eye instead of Sauron's Eye'. Would that not seem 'out of place' in LOTR? The category also specifically said 'Really crazy builds are welcome!!'. So I felt this easily fell within the category prompt.
Quoting Brick Ninja
Quoting Oliver Becker
Quoting Elio Salsano
 I like it 
  August 5, 2017
You're a very good builder and I like many of your skills you've showed here, John! In your fine final creation I miss a little suspense and LOTR- athmosphere... ;)
 I like it 
  August 5, 2017
Simply wonderful.
  August 4, 2017
First off we have two amazing builds. I am going to write up the reviews/vote all in one. Classical better captured the original feel, his really feels like Dol Guldur, where John's feels less like Minas Morgul. However with no stipulation to base the build off of the movies or Alan Lee/John Howe's painting, this doesn't impact much. John wins in the presentation of the build. His build presents itself well, with the white walls, and the very blue water. Classical's is a little more monochromatic. Which has its own charm, but doesn't stand out as well. Classical wins in rockwork, his seems more natural and varied, where John's seems more repetitive. I'm calling it a draw on the brick work. Classical's is more old/worn and detailed, but John's is new and clean with nice crenellations and color variations. Classical wins foliage, more detailed, diverse, and natural looking. Classical wins, fitting in the category. Although neither one of you really emphasized the implications of the sides being switch. Classical covered it better , with the Black council figures and the overall feel of the build. Classical's feels like a good guys castle in LotR, where John's feels more out of place in LotR. Final thoughts: John: You have a phenomenal build, it is clean, picturesque, and dynamic. It is an overall amazing build. Classical: You have a great build with lots of good details and nice techniques. It is not as striking as John's, but fits the contest better. For this reason Classical gets my vote. This was a really tough call and you both did absolutely fantastic. Thanks for entering.
  August 3, 2017
Both of your entries were excellent. I had a VERY hard time deciding which one to vote for, but in the end, I voted for John. I felt that he used more unique and interesting techniques than Classical, though I felt that Classical captured the feel of his chosen place better. Excellent work both of you! ~Jonathan Demers
 I like it 
  August 1, 2017
The rounded layout really sells this as Minas Morgul, especially with those battlements. Amazing how smoothly you pulled off the rounded towers. Those figs are really epic too!
 I like it 
  July 31, 2017
Excellent work!
 I like it 
  July 31, 2017
Hi John, Your opponent gets my vote. I left a long comment at his build, where I explain my choice. Good luck with the other judges. Greetz, elio
 I like it 
  July 30, 2017
Impressive work here, John! I love all the little details you added and I really like your battlement design. The colour scheme also works very well and sticks out in a good way. My only critique is the rockwork. For some reason, it doesn't seem to match the rest of your build and seems rather out of place - a blocky section in an otherwise very refined and polished MOC. Good luck with the judges! I have a feeling it's going to be close.
 I like it 
  July 30, 2017
You both did very well in this final round, but I decided to give my vote to your opponent.
 I like it 
  July 30, 2017
Wow.... Just, wow!!! :D Good luck!!! Although you probally don't need it!! ;)
 I like it 
  July 30, 2017
Let me start off by saying that both of you have built an exceptional set of entries in this contest, and it was an honor judging them. While both of you equally deserve this title, I have to decide on one winner, so let me start nitpicking. Both of you transformed an evil fortress into a more peaceful, majestic castle, and you both excelled at that. John, your choice of using white bricks gives the castle a more "noble" feel. I rarely see white in a castle, but you made it work. Also, your battlements were the best part of the build for me. Meanwhile, your opponent went for a standard light bley castle, however he did a better job at adding texture. While your opponent had more complex rockwork, he did leave one edge untouched which was not to my liking. Both of you did well on scenery, but yours was far superior. In essence, you have my vote in what was an extremely close match. Good luck with the remaining judges, even though you probably won't need it! :P
 I like it 
  July 30, 2017
Amazing Work, Absolutely love it!
 I like it 
  July 30, 2017
31 pounds and 20 pence in paper money or in coins? Either one seems somewhat light for a MOC this size.
 I like it 
  July 30, 2017
Awesome! Great design for the top part of the buildings and very nice choice of colors too. And those windows (for lack of a better word in english) look great :-)
 I like it 
  July 29, 2017
31 pounds? Dang. Amazing build! I really like the detail and water!
 I like it 
  July 29, 2017
To your credit, the first thing I thought of when I saw this castle was Minas Morgul, even though, without knowing the category or that this was for MELO, I imagined you'd just built a cool looking castle that happened to be reminiscent of the Witch King's fortress.
 I like it 
  July 29, 2017
Classical has better bring out the best in himself, because otherwise, you stole the show! This model is fantastic!
 I like it 
  July 29, 2017
Very nice work. The rocks are great. Before I'd even read the description I recognised this as a good Minas Morgul! =)
 I like it 
  July 29, 2017
Awesome! Good luck to you and classical!
 I like it 
  July 29, 2017
A brilliant fantasy castle build, packed with detail! Love the fresh new color scheme and the aesthetic in general!
 I like it 
  July 28, 2017
Awesome John! Epic build, and a good story behind it, the colors flow brilliantly yet pop very nicely! Keep it up and good luck with the judges! :D
 
By John Snyder
Add to my favorite builders

46
people like this. See who.

1,461 visitors
25 comments
Added July 28, 2017
 


LEGO models my own creation MOCpages toys shop MELO R6: John Snyder vs. Classical BricksCastle


You Your home page | LEGO creations | Favorite builders
Activity Activity | Comments | Creations
Explore Explore | Recent | Groups
MOCpages is an unofficial, fan-created website. LEGO® and the brick configuration are property of The LEGO Group, which does not sponsor, own, or endorse this site.
©2002-2017 Sean Kenney Design Inc | Privacy policy | Terms of use