MOCpages : Share your LEGO® creations
LEGO models my own creation MOCpages toys shop Finger topsOther
Welcome to the world's greatest LEGO fan community!
Explore cool creations, share your own, and have lots of fun together.  ~  It's all free!
Finger tops
Rate it  12345       Add a comment Add a comment   Zoom in  Zoom in
So many tops, so little time.
About this creation
Please feel free to look over the images and skip the verbiage.

Introduction

TopRun time (sec)           TopRun time (sec)
Ninjago102Motorcycle Wheel 2      28
Stack-of-Dishes82Lotus23
X-pod74Asteroid22
Fabuland48Square19
Motorcycle Wheel 147Centrifuge18
Down Under42Glow16
Motorcycle Wheel 3   36Lime15
Racing Stripe33Sawtooth15
Tank top32Honeycomb14
Flop3




Introduction

A finger top is one that can be spun up to good effect with a simple twirl of the fingers. This page just scratches the surface of the finger tops waiting to be built in the LEGOŽ realm. Since posting this page, I've made dozens more with no end in sight.



The 19 LEGOŽ tops in the video above and group shots below have 2 important things in common: (i) All qualify as finger tops, though some are easier to twirl than others. (ii) All stay up at least 3 sec, and all but 2 spin longer than 12 sec.





Of the 19 finger tops shown above, 1 spins longer than 100 sec, 3 longer than 60 sec, 6 longer than 40 sec, and 9 longer than 30 sec.

Close-ups of 17 of these tops follow -- roughly in order of decreasing best run times. The 2 tops included in the group shots but not featured here are (i) the DGB 3-arm top (12 sec) at far upper right in the overhead group shot, and (ii) the orange and black 3-arm top (5 sec) near top center in the same photo.

For completeness, this page also has a bit to say about my Asteroid top, which had to be cannibalized temporarily to make the Centrifuge top shown below.

The best run times reported here were obtained on polished fine-grained granite, a nearly ideal supporting surface. They beat best times on the porcelain tile floor in the video by a good 10-30%.




Ninjago: 102 sec, 0.043 kg

My longest-running finger top by far -- and the only one to break the 100-second barrier when this page was first posted -- is based on a Ninjago spinner.



The spinner's well-balanced built-in weight boosts run times by (i) lowering the top's center of mass (CM), and (ii) adding just the right amount of axial rotational inertia (aka moment of inertia).



The superstructure is just there to provide a stable stem, as the spinner itself lacks a central axle hole.



The infrastructure is just a mount for one of top's most important components -- the custom tip.

Modifications made after these photos were taken took spin time to 158 sec -- mainly via (i) a lighter superstructure and (ii) a new tip cut from the end of a round-tipped 4L antenna.

The photo below shows the new tip in use in one of my Klingon tops. In fact, all of my tops now use this tip. Most use the 2x2 dome mount shown below as well, but that mount is too high for a Ninjago spinner-based top.



More info on the Ninjago top's MOCpage.



Stack-of-Dishes: 82 sec, 0.062 kg

Aerodynamics count for a lot in the top biz. The 2nd longest-running finger top in this early collection owes much of its endurance to streamlining. High axial rotational inertia and a lower than average center of mass also contribute.







Stack-of-Dishes runs so smoothly and quietly that it sometimes appears to be frozen in time rather than spinning. My best sleeper, it stays bolt upright until the bitter end.



X-pod: 74 sec, 0.027 kg

This simple, long-running top is just an X-pod container, and axle, and a tip.



X-pod sleeps occasionally but, like Down Under, strongly prefers to precess when twirled.



Fabuland: 48 sec, 0.044 kg

The big yellow top below is built around a pair of Fabuland merry-go-round bases (4750) joined base-to-base. It also likes to precess.





The top on the left is Motorcycle Wheel 1.



Motorcycle Wheel 1: 47 sec, 0.013 kg

Technic motorcycle wheels make great rotors. Heavy rims and lightweight spokes add up to high axial rotational inertia per unit mass -- exactly what you want in a high-speed top rotor.



This simple top (right) uses a single DBG motorcycle wheel for a rotor. Honeycomb is on its left in this shot.



Same top, now upside down and with Fabuland on its right.



Down Under: 42 sec, 0.028 kg

This very simple, long-running top (left) is little more than an inverted 11x11 LU hemisphere, a stem, and a tip.



Like X-pod, it will sleep but would much rather precess at a liesurely pace. That's Glow on its right.



Motorcycle Wheel 3: 36 sec, 0.059 kg

Twirling 3 motorcycle wheels and two 10x10 dishes at once isn't easy, but practice pays.



This top is my 2nd best sleeper after Stack-of-Dishes.



Racing Stripe: 33 sec, 0.032 kg

Racing Stripe is the B&W top with the racing stripe in the right foreground below. It has a very nice feel as it spins up. The shimmering wagon-wheel illusions it triggers when spinning are the best in this collection.





Tank top: 32 sec, 0.110 kg

At ~0.1 kg each, Tank top, Centrifuge, and Asteroid are by far the heaviest tops here. All 3 take muscle and practice to twirl -- especially Tank top, as it has the highest axial rotational inertia of all. The good news: Tank top has the lowest topple speed of all by a wide margin.





Most of Tank top's mass and therefore axial rotational inertia resides in the pre-stressed outer ring of inverted large tread links, as desired. The spokes are strong but light.



Motorcycle Wheel 2: 28 sec, 0.057 kg

The rotor on this top consists of pair of white motorcycle wheels clamped between a pair of clear 10x10 dishes



The 4x4x6 B&W cylinder above the rotor was originally just a fancy timing mark for my laser tachometer. Now it's just there for looks. The top would run a good bit longer with a lower center of mass.



Lotus: 23 sec, 0.037 kg

Lotus is the B&W top with 6 "petals" in the left foreground below. Like Racing Stripe on its right, it generates excellent wagon-wheel illusions when spinning.





Asteroid: 22 sec, ~0.1 kg

Like Centrifuge and Tank top, twirling Asteroid (below) takes muscle and practice.







As with Centrifuge and Tank top, Asteroid's run times are limited by (i) high overall mass, (ii) high CM, (iii) poor aerodynamics, and (iv) low release speeds due to very high axial rotational inertia.

More info on Asteroid's MOCpage.



Square: 19 sec, 0.023 kg

Square is the litte white and DBG top with the square rotor at upper center in the photo below. Like Racing Stripe and Lotus in the foreground, it has a very satisfying feel when twirled.



Run times suffer from (i) a relatively high CM, (ii) so-so aerodynamics, and (iii) low rotational inertia ratio.

The rotational inertia ratio of a top is given by Iaxial / Itransverse, where Iaxial is the rotational inertia of the top about its spin axis, and Itransverse is the maximum rotational inertia about an axis perpendicular to the spin axis and through the CM. For maximum stability and run time, this ratio should be much greater than 1.

Compare Square with Stack-of-Dishes, Fabuland, and Tank top, all of which have very high rotational inertia ratios.



Centrifuge: 18 sec, ~0.1 kg

What better place to demonstrate centrigual force than on top of a spinning top?





The very soft bronze centrifuge return spring peeking out from between the white wheels of the centrifuge is the only non-LEGOŽ part used in all 20 tops.





This large, heavy top uses the same ring and hub as Asteroid.



Glow: 16 sec, 0.026 kg



The black and white 4L light saber blades sticking up from the corners of Glow's rotor (right) induce dandy wagon-wheel illusions when the lights are on. (That's Down Under on the left.)



Things get even more interesting when the lights go out.



Sawtooth: 15 sec, 0.016

This very lightweight top is usually well-behaved -- until it lands, anyway. Would've been well-behaved in the video, too, if I'd remembered to put its tip back on.





There's no simple way to fix a saw blade like this to an axle -- hence the Technic rubber bushes serving as friction clutches.



Lime: 15 sec, mass not available

The lime green top at upper left in the photo below benefits from a very low CM but suffers even more from excessive air resistance. The hissing sound it makes when spinning is second only to that made by Honeycomb.



Lime is better seen in the video and the group shot below.





Honeycomb: 14 sec on granite, 0.041 kg

Honeycomb is of course the red and gray top on the left. As with Lime, excessive air resistance is its only real flaw. (That's Motorcycle Wheel 1 on its right.)



Stud-generated aerodynamic drag is a braking force to be reckoned with in a fast-spinning LEGOŽ top -- especially when the studs are far from the spin axis. Large rotor perforations are even worse in this regard. The loud hiss Honeycomb emits when spinning is the sound of drag braking.



Flop: 3 sec, 0.031 kg



This floppy top, made from ancient Technic suspension arms, may be the shortest-running top on this page, but it's still a lot of fun.



Comments

 I made it 
  February 1, 2015
Quoting Nick Barrett Quite a collection! Interesting stuff, makes me want to crack open the wheel drawer, see what spins best.
Nick, thanks. I hope you do. I'd love to see what you come up with.
 I like it 
  February 1, 2015
Quite a collection! Interesting stuff, makes me want to crack open the wheel drawer, see what spins best.
Jeremy McCreary
 I like it 
Matt Bace
  January 30, 2015
Very cool! I've never seen this done in LEGO before. Before reading your entire post, my money was on the stack of dishes for best performance, and it looks like it did pretty well.
 I made it 
  January 30, 2015
Bingo! Video showing all 19 tops in action finally embedded successfully. Please check it out.
 I like it 
  January 30, 2015
Just wow. Thanks for the different designs as well. Keep building!
 I made it 
  January 30, 2015
Quoting Nils O. Very cool, so many spinning tops. My favourites are the Centrifuge Top and the Hex Tops. Great job! :-)) P.S.: My little son likes spinning tops a lot, he would love yours, too :-))
Very kind, Nils. The Centrifuge is one of my favorites, too, but I've just scratched the surface here. I look forward to seeing the tops you and your son create.
 I like it 
  January 30, 2015
Very cool, so many spinning tops. My favourites are the Centrifuge Top and the Hex Tops. Great job! :-)) P.S.: My little son likes spinning tops a lot, he would love yours, too :-))
 
By Jeremy McCreary
Add to my favorite builders

8
people like this. See who.

2,039 visitors
7 comments
Added January 30, 2015
 


LEGO models my own creation MOCpages toys shop Finger topsOther


You Your home page | LEGO creations | Favorite builders
Activity Activity | Comments | Creations
Explore Explore | Recent | Groups
MOCpages is an unofficial, fan-created website. LEGO® and the brick configuration are property of The LEGO Group, which does not sponsor, own, or endorse this site.
©2002-2018 Sean Kenney Design Inc | Privacy policy | Terms of use